Security/Reviews/WebRTC

Item Reviewed

WebRTC
Target	https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=665909

Introduce the Feature

Goal of Feature, what is trying to be achieved (problem solved, use cases, etc)

What solutions/approaches were considered other than the proposed solution?

Why was this solution chosen?

Any security threats already considered in the design and why?

Threat Brainstorming

Status

Identity (TEMPLATE)
Tracker Bug	-
Stage	Definition
Status	Red (Green, Yellow, Red?)
Release Target
Health	-
Status Note	-

Team

Product manager
Feature manager	-
Engineering lead
Security lead
Product Security lead
Privacy lead
Localization lead	-
Accessibility lead	-
QA lead	-
UX lead	-
Product marketing lead	-
Additional members	-

Open issues/risks

Stage 1: Definition

Introduction

Include brief summary of feature/project, and link back to core feature/product pages.

Use Cases

Data Flows

Diagram

File:TEMPLATE-Protocol.png

1. Section 1

ID	Origin	Destination	Description
1.A	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop.
1.B	klmnop	klmnop klmnop	klmnop klmnop klmnop klmnop. klmnop klmnopklmnopklmnop

2. Section 2

ID	Origin	Destination	Description
2.A	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop.
2.B	klmnop	klmnop klmnop	klmnop klmnop klmnop klmnop. klmnop klmnopklmnopklmnop

3. Section 3

ID	Origin	Destination	Description
3.A	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop	Abcdefg hij klmnop.
3.B	klmnop	klmnop klmnop	klmnop klmnop klmnop klmnop. klmnop klmnopklmnopklmnop

Architecture Diagram

Stage 2: Design

Threat Model

ID	Title	Threat	Proposed Mitigations	Threat Agent	Rating	Likelihood	Notes	Impact	Notes
1	Title text	Threat description	Proposed mitigation.	Threat agents	Rating #	Likelihood #	Notes.	Impact Score # – Impact	Notes.
2	Title text	Threat description	Proposed mitigation.	Threat agents	Rating #	Likelihood #	Notes.	Impact Score # – Impact	Notes.
3	Title text	Threat description	Proposed mitigation.	Threat agents	Rating #	Likelihood #	Notes.	Impact Score # – Impact	Notes.

User Interactions

ID	Summary	Description
1.A	Summary	Description.
1.B	Summary	Description.
2.A	Summary	Description.
2.B	Summary	Description.

Client Interactions

ID	Summary	Description
2.A	Summary	Description.

Server Interactions

ID	Summary	Description	Path	Input	Output	CEF	CSRF
3.A	Summary	Description	Path	Input	Output	CEF	CSRF
3.b	Summary	Description	Path	Input	Output	CEF	CSRF

CEF and CSRF columns indicate wether or not CEF logging or CSRF prevention is required for the interactions

Security Recommendations / Open Issues

ID	Title	Status	Summary
[[1]]	Title	Status(Open/Closed)	Summary.
[[2]]	Title	Status(Open/Closed)	Summary.

CEF Logging Requirements

Business Test Cases

Document application specific test cases here

Privacy Risk Analysis

(Status of and link to privacy review and outcome here)

Stage 3: Planning

Application Security Requirements

Document individual requirements for the application here (e.g. CEF logging, captcha, etc)

Operation Security Requirements

Document network/platform security requirements here (e.g. IDS concerns, firewall changes, system hardening reqs, etc)

Mana Website Creation Form

• https://mana.mozilla.org/wiki/display/websites/Home

Critical Security Requirements

Itemize individual security blockers here. Reference components in section AppSec or OpSec subsections. These blockers must be addressed before the product can go live.

Stage 4: Development

Repeatable Security Test Cases

Document individual repeatable security test cases here. Include a reference to the source repo, and documentation that governs how to execute test cases.

Secure Coding Guidelines

Document specific secure coding guidelines to be followed and relate them to specific issues/requirements that are specified; capture bug ids related to those issues.

Code Review Milestones

Table 1 - itemized list of code review milestones {i.e. breakdown of specific components that will be reviewed} Table 2 - list of app components/modules that should trigger additional security review (e.g. auth, csrf, file upload handling, etc)

Stage 5: Release

Application Security Verification

These subsections should contain a list of the steps to be taken, and the status of each activity

Code Review

Automated Security Testing

• Garmr

Manual Security Testing

Operational Security Verification

ArcSight Information

Network Design Security Review

Database Security Review

Platform Security (Hardening & Specific Config Requirements)

Landing Criteria

This should be a table itemizing everything from Stage 3 - Critical Security Requirements, including status. For status Red=Unimplemented,Yellow=implemented,Green=tested and passed?

Stage 6: Post Implementation Review

Production Security Considerations

Document additional/ongoing work for this application (e.g. specific things to watch for in ArcSight, gaming behaviour, etc)

Post Implementation Tasks

Itemize process/kb changes developed from this project (e.g. secure coding guidelines, policy stuff, etc)

Team status notes

	status	notes
Products	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-
Engineering	tbd	-

Action Items

Action Item Status
Release Target
Action Items