QA/Reader view

From MozillaWiki
< QA
Jump to: navigation, search

Desktop Reader View

Ownership

Developer contacts: Margaret Leibovic, Blair McBride, Jared Wein

QA Lead: Andrei Vaida, :avaida on IRC

Status

Overview

[LANDED] Nightly 38: first landed, disabled by defualt

[LANDED] Aurora 38: landed, currently enabled by default

[LANDED] Beta 38: landed, disabled by default

[ON TRACK] Release 38: tbd

Timeline

  • UPDATE 2015-03-05: the pref is true by default on 39.0a1.
  • UPDATE 2015-03-06: the pref has been switched back to false by default on 39.0a1, as it triggered Bug 1139250 and Bug 1139678.
  • UPDATE 2015-03-09: the pref has been switched back to true by default on 39.0a1, as the perf regressions it caused have been fixed/mitigated.
  • UPDATE 2015-03-27: the pref is true by default on 38.0a2.
  • UPDATE 2015-03-31: the pref is true by default on 38.0b1.

Risk analysis

Event Probability Impact Current situation Mitigation steps
Website fails to be displayed in Reader View. probable high Some websites can't be displayed in Reader View, although the option is available for them. Reader View detection improvements are being tracked in Bug 1102450.
Website fails to be displayed properly in Reader View. probable high Since web content varies a lot, some web pages are not displayed properly in Reader View. Reader View detection improvements are being tracked in Bug 1102450
The type controls [Aa] are not working properly. probable medium There were no recent bugs or regressions affecting this functionality. Periodical regression testing covers this area.
Adding a website to Reading List fails to work. probable high This feature is currently being added to Reader View and cannot be assessed at this time. Periodical regression testing covers this area.
The reading list toggle button is not working. improbable medium This feature is currently being added to Reader View and cannot be assessed at this time. Periodical regression testing covers this area.
Reader View is not easily accessible and user exposure is significantly reduced. improbable high Reader View can be accessed from the Location Bar, Bookmarks Menu, via keyboard shortcut and also through feature advertisements. Periodical regression testing covers this area.
Web pages displayed in Reader View are missing content. frequent high Many websites are missing various types of content while displayed in Reader View. Reader View content display optimizations are being tracked in Bug 1139165.

Summary

Context

Reader View for Firefox Desktop is based on the browser bookmarklet called Readability and its counterpart, the Firefox Readibility add-on. Its goal is to improve how content is displayed in the browser.

Viewing a webpage in Reader View will remove most of its site elements - (i.e.) menus, ads, social media widgets, etc. and replace the font and overall color scheme styling of the website with a more readable one.

The features available in Reader View:

  • change the font size and type
  • change the color scheme
  • open the Reading List sidebar
  • add or remove the current item from the Reading List

Enabling the feature

Reader View is available starting with Firefox 38 and it can be enabled by setting the following pref to true:

reader.enabled [1]

To enable parse-on-load for Reader View, set the following pref to true:

reader.parse-on-load.enabled [2]

[1] please note that this pref has not yet landed, so there's no actual way to enable/disable Reader View
[2] please not that this pref only enables parse-on-load for the Reader View

References

  • The planned UX for Reader View is available here.
  • The specifications for Reader View are available here.
  • The font type to be used in Reader View is available here.

Test cases

Overview

Targeted scenarios

Testing focused on basic functionality

  • Enable Reader View
  • Disable Reader View
  • Enter Reader View from the location bar button
  • Change font size in Reader View from the sidebar controls
  • Change font type in Reader View from the sidebar controls
  • Change color scheme in Reader View from the sidebar controls
  • Read a web page in Reader View
  • Toggle the Reading List from the sidebar controls
  • Add item to Reading List from Reader View sidebar controls
  • Exit Reader View from the sidebar controls
  • Exit Reader View from the location bar button

Testing focused on interoperability

  • Open the Reading List while in Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Add page to local Reading List while in Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Bookmark a web page while in Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Bookmark a web page and enter Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Open a link from History and enter Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Open bookmarked web page and enter Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Open a web page in a new window and enter Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Navigate back and forward from a web page while in Reader View (non-pb & pb)
  • Enter Reader View and restart the browser
  • Enter Reader View for a web page opened in a new tab, close the tab and restore it from History (non-pb & pb)
  • Open the same web page in two distinct tabs and enter Reader View in each of them (non-pb & pb)
  • Open two different web pages in two different windows and enter Reader View in each of them (non-pb & pb)
  • Enter Reader View and add the page to a FxA’s associated Reading List (non-pb & pb)
  • Sync a bookmark using FxA, open it and enter Reader View
  • Sync a bookmark using FxA, open it, enter Reader View and add it to Reading List
  • Zoom in and zoom out from a page displayed in Reader View
  • Use Reader View while having a high contrast OS theme set
  • Enter Reader View from a pinned tab (non-pb & pb)
  • Enter Reader View and pin the tab (non-pb & pb)
  • Check image scaling in Reader View while resizing the browser window (non-pb & pb)
  • Use Reader View with Firefox Developer Edition theme
  • Use Reader View with lightweight (persona) themes
  • Use Reader View with complete themes

Testing based on recent bugs and regressions

  • Enter Reader View using keyboard shortcuts [CTRL] / [CMD] + [L] then press [RETURN]
  • Enter Reader View using keyboard shortcuts [CTRL] / [CMD] + [L] then press [SPACE]
  • Navigate back and forth from a web page displayed in Reader View
  • Check the :active, :hover, :focus states of the Reader View button
  • Enter and exit Reader View while toggling a high contrast OS theme
  • Enter Reader View from a pinned tab
  • Use Reader View with lightweight, complete and Developer Edition themes
  • Readability.js displays web pages properly, with no missing content
  • Check all the Reader View tooltips
  • Pin a website displayed in Reader View, reload that pinned tab from a second, regular tab

Testing Reader View with e10s

All regular test cases already available in test suites will be executed with e10s enabled.

Bug work

Tracking bug

meta: Bug 558882 - (desktop-reader) Ship Readability in the desktop browser (reader mode)

Bug triage +/- for verification

[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1129989 - ReaderParent.jsm doesn't need to be pre-processed
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1125396 - TypeError: message.target.messageManager is undefined in ReaderParent
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1125364 - TypeError: content is null in AboutReaderListener
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1113795 - Show something useful when a user visits about:reader without a URL parameter
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1128724 - "Print" reader mode theme name is confusing
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 795968 - Create the about:reader page
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1132656 - Reader mode toolbar overlaps content if window becomes too narrow.
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1132659 - Refine active/selected/hover state for Light/Dark/Sepia controls
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1124271 - Clicking the reader mode button in an app tab opens reader mode in a new tab
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1135351 - Ugly hover and active state on reader mode button
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1123910 - "about:reader" URL in location bar isn't user-friendly
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1131303 - Implement strings for Reader Mode toolbar controls
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1135553 - Reader Mode's "Type controls" popup is not dismissed when clicking in the page's left or right margins, only in text
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1134658 - Reader mode icon looks bad with lightweight themes
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1124011 - Enable the reader mode toolbar button on Nightly
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1139174 - Ship Georgia and Helvetica/Arial as Reader View Fonts until Fira and Charis land
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1132307 - Use <button> elements instead of <a> elements in reader mode toolbar
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1142217 - Make the Add/Remove to Reading List toggle button of the reader view actually work
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1134497 - Implement infopanels for in-product FTU Reading List/View tour
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1134501 - UITour: force page into Reader View if current URL = FTU URL
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1134507 - Implement infopanels to promote Reader View / Reading List when first seen
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1139678 - <Regression> Fx-Team-Non-PGO - Tp5 Optimized caused by background readability parsing
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1140172 - Use a single worker for background readability parsing
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1141757 - Non-intermittent "Full message: TypeError: doc.documentElement is undefined" errors causing Talos bustage to be misstarred
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1138628 - Don't try to find article in reader mode cache on desktop until we actually store articles in cache
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1117258 - Implement CSS styling for desktop about:reader content
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1142298 - Light/Dark/Sepia controls in reader view aren't aligned properly
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1144117 - Saving the reading view page also saves the left bar properly
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1137211 - Font panel in reading view should disappear when clicking on the margins
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1135009 - Printing in reader mode cuts off on the left (sidebar overlays text)
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1144749 - Create reader mode keyboard shortcut
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1128916 - Inline article images are not aligned properly in reader mode on desktop
[QE-VERIFY?] Bug 1143844 - Be smarter about whether or not to show the reader toolbar button
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1146373 - Images in reader view are sometimes too small
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1147122 - Restore reader view error message if about:reader fails when user clicks reader button
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1147337 - Reader View bounces back or loading white page when escaped characters exists in URL
[QE-VERIFY?] Bug 1135364 - close <meta> tag in aboutReader.html
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1147889 - need transition when switching between light-dark-sepia
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1148098 - Enable Reader Mode for Firefox 38+
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1141618 - Put reader worker logging behind a pref
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1147571 - Inconsistent thumbnail generation depending on whether you're in reader mode
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1148189 - Block images sometimes lack bottom margin
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1143844 - Be smarter about whether or not to show the reader toolbar button
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1149520 - Reader mode toolbar repaints during font size change
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1127337 - Show article favicon in reader mode
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1150759 - The Reader Mode toolbar should use proper RTL styling.
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1139026 - Use different text highlight color in dark theme
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1153371 - Create shared place for readability content CSS styles
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1153485 - Create shared place for desktop/Android AboutReaderListener logic
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1153775 - Add same spacing to the right side of Reader View than to the left
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1150695 - Move isProbablyReaderable function to Readability.js
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1149261 - Improve the Reader View Close Button

Bug fix verification

[VERI] Bug 1131458 - ReaderMode button in the URLbar isn't accessible

2015-02-17: verified fixed on 38.0a1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1128724 - "Print" reader mode theme name is confusing

2015-02-19: verified fixed on 38.0a1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1120735 - Implement desktop reader mode controls

2015-02-25: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms; new issues filed

[VERI] Bug 907079 - The forward button is displayed after opening and closing the reader mode settings menu

2015-03-09: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 795981 - Add a reader mode button to the location bar
[VERI] Bug 795968 - Create the about:reader page

2015-02-19: verified fixed on 38.0a1 and 37.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1124271 - Clicking the reader mode button in an app tab opens reader mode in a new tab

2015-02-25: verified fixed on 39.0a1, across platforms
2015-03-30: verified fixed on 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1136716 - Discrepancy between the tooltip displayed for the two Reader Mode close buttons

2015-03-05: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1124011 - Enable the reader mode toolbar button on Nightly

2015-03-05: verified fixed on 39.0a1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1131303 - Implement strings for Reader Mode toolbar controls

2015-03-10: verified fixed on 39.0a1, 38.0a2 across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1132307 - Use <button> elements instead of <a> elements in reader mode toolbar

2015-03-10: verified fixed on 39.0a1, 38.0a2 across platforms; see also Bug 1135589
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1134441 - Replace font size controls with +/- buttons

2015-03-19: verified fixed on 39.0a1, 38.0a2 across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1135009 - Printing in reader mode cuts off on the left (sidebar overlays text)

2015-03-20: verified fixed on 39.0a1, across platforms
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1142298 - Fix reader view font/color control glitches

2015-03-20: verified fixed on 39.0a1, across platforms
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1135351 - Ugly hover and active state on reader mode button

2015-03-23: verified fixed on 39.0a1, across platforms; see also Bug 1140345

[VERI] Bug 1146666 - reader view available for direct load but not via homepage of @medium

2015-03-30: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1146358 - The attempt of adding a page to Reading List from Reader View fails and causes an error

2015-03-30: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1142217 - Make the Add/Remove to Reading List toggle button of the reader view actually work

2015-03-30: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1134658 - Reader mode icon looks bad with lightweight themes

2015-03-30: verified fixed on 39.0a1 and 38.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1148098 - Enable Reader Mode for Firefox 38+

2015-04-02: verified fixed on 38.0b1-build1 (20150330154247), across platforms
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1147122 - Restore reader view error message if about:reader fails when user clicks reader button

2015-04-02: verified fixed on 40.0a1 and 39.0a2, across platforms
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1133732 - Reader Mode button remains in active/hover state after toggling it

2015-04-02: verified fixed on 40.0a1 and 39.0a2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1135589 - The focusring for the controls in reader mode doesn't match the visible borders of the buttons

2015-04-02: verified fixed on 39.0a2, across platforms; side-effect on Linux

[VERI] Bug 1137211 - Font panel in reading view should disappear when clicking on the margins

2015-04-06: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms; follow-up bug filed for Linux
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1148462 - When "Reading List" is disabled (browser.readinglist.enabled = false) CTRL+ALT+R should not open its sidebar.

2015-04-06: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1139026 - Use different text highlight color in dark theme

2015-04-06: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms
2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1147889 - need transition when switching between light-dark-sepia

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1132656 - Reader mode toolbar overlaps content if window becomes too narrow.

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1145809 - reader view footer area

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1134446 - Automatically open the ReadingList sidebar the first time ReaderMode is used

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1146373 - Images in reader view are sometimes too small

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b2-build1 (20150406174117), by Catalin Suciu

[VERI] Bug 1149261 - Improve the Reader View Close Button

2015-04-07: verified fixed on 38.0b4-build1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1150862 - Make about:reader un-linkable from content

2015-04-20: verified fixed on 40.0a1, 39.0a2, 38.0b5-build1, using Ubuntu 14.04 (x64)

[VERI] Bug 1149068 - Reading List Toolbar Sans Serif font selection always displays Helvetica (not the font that is used)

2015-04-21: verified fixed on 38.0b6-build1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1147337 - Reader View bounces back or loading white page when escaped characters exists in URL

2015-04-21: verified fixed on 38.0b6-build1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1158960 - Reader view is broken in e10s mode

2015-04-29: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1158322 - Sidebar affects a page while printing

2015-04-30: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms
2015-05-11: verified fixed on 39.0a2 and 38.0.5b1-build1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1154028 - Make sure reader view UI styles don't accidentally get applied to readability content

2015-04-30: verified fixed on 38.0b9-build1

[VERI] Bug 1158281 - Match Pocket's Reader View Sepia Theme

2015-05-04: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms
2015-05-12: verified fixed on 38.0.5b1-build2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1160577 - Error message is no longer shown when a page isn't readable

2015-05-08: verified fixed on 40.0a1, across platforms
2015-05-12: verified fixed on 38.0.5b1-build2, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1157682 - Should ignore query string / hashes for checking for "home page"

2015-05-11: verified fixed on 40.0a1, 39.0a2 and 38.0.5b1-build1, across platforms

[VERI] Bug 1157197 - Please enable reader view for 38.0.5

2015-05-11: verified fixed on 38.0.5b1-build1, across platforms
Logged bugs

Bug 1133732 - ReaderMode button remains in active/hover state after toggling it

2015-02-17: bug caused by the implementation made in Bug 1131458.

Bug 1135587 - Reader Mode is not compatible with high contrast Windows themes

2015-02-23: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 795981

Bug 1135589 - Clicking a button from the controls sidebar places a selection rectangle on it

2015-02-23: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 795981

Bug 1135593 - The Reader Mode controls sidebar is affected by page zoom actions
Bug 1136704 - The Reader Mode button styling is inconsistent with the Developer Edition theme

2015-02-25: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 795981
2015-03-06: marked as a DUPE of Bug 1134658 by Justin Dolske

Bug 1136716 - Discrepancy between the tooltip displayed for the two Reader Mode close buttons

2015-02-25: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1120735

Bug 1142499 - Reloading a pinned tab while Reader View is active leads to a highlighted favicon

2015-03-12: found by Ada Lucinet while running Reader View test cases; affects 39.0a1 and 38.0a2

Bug 1143708 - Page should not be loaded in Reader Mode after the pref was disabled

2015-03-16: found by Cornel Ionce while running Reader View test cases; affects 39.0a1 and 38.0a2
2015-03-16: marked as WONTFIX by Margaret Leibovic

Bug 1151415 - [Linux] Focus rings are displayed in Reader View for the buttons available in the font panel

2015-04-06: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1135589

Bug 1151732 - The font panel from Reader View should disappear when clicking the Reading List sidebar button

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1137211

Bug 1151734 - The font panel from Reader View should disappear when clicking an empty area from inside the Reading List sidebar

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1137211

Bug 1151735 - The font panel from Reader View should disappear when selecting text from the page

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1137211

Bug 1151737 - The font panel from Reader View should disappear when clicking the add/remove Reading List buttons

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1137211

Bug 1151793 - The Reader View body should have a minimum width set

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1145809

Bug 1151795 - The Reading List remove button from Reader View's footer is not adapting to high-contrast themes

2015-04-07: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1145809

Bug 1156211 - There's no hover styling available for the Reader View Location Bar button on Mac OS X

2015-04-20: found while verifying the fix pushed for Bug 1148562
2015-04-22: marked as resolved wontfix by Gijs Kruitbosch

Bug 1157123 - The bottom border of the Serif button displays an escaping pixel at its left side

2015-04-20: found while validating build1 of 38.0b6

Bug 1158071 - NoScript interferes with Reader View mode

2015-04-24: found while validating build1 of 38.0b6

Bug 1163519 - ReaderParent.jsm:95:12 throws an error in the Browser Console when clicking the "Enter Reader View" button from the Location Bar

2015-05-11: found while validating build1 of 38.0.5b1

Bug 1163523 - Clicking the body of a page displayed in Reader View places a focus ring on it

2015-05-11: found while validating build1 of 38.0.5b1

Readability.js

Issues related to how web content itself is being displayed in Reader View, (e.g.) missing paragraphs, wrong author name, etc. will be filed with the Readability repository.

Bug triage +/- for verification

[QE-VERIFY?] Bug 1125711 - First paragraph missing from parsed article
[QE-VERIFY?] Bug 1137258 - Reader View hides various paragraphs and headlines in an article
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1139165 - Optimize Reader View for Popular, Tech and Design Websites
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1146666 - reader view available for direct load but not via homepage of @medium
[QE-VERIFY-] Bug 1147626 - Refine isProbablyReaderable algorithm
[QE-VERIFY+] Bug 1149057 - Reader View not working with SUMO Articles

Bug fix verification

[VERI] Bug 809724 - First paragraph of NYTimes article in reader mode is at the end of the document

2015-03-19: verified fixed on 39.0a1, using Windows 7 (x64); left the bug open for the mobile-side confirmation

[VERI] Bug 1137258 - Reader View hides various paragraphs and headlines in an article

2015-03-19: verified fixed on 39.0a1, using Windows 7 (x64)

[VERI] Bug 1125711 - First paragraph missing from parsed article

2015-03-19: verified fixed on 39.0a1, using Windows 7 (x64)

[VERI] Bug 1143844 - Be smarter about whether or not to show the reader toolbar button

2015-04-16: verified fixed on 38.0b4-build1, using Windows 7 (x64)
Logged bugs

#104 - Readability fails on pages from nytimes.com with query string parameters attached to their URL

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-14: closed by Gijs Kruitbosch (:gijsk) as fixed; Bug 1147337 was referenced

#105 - Shorter articles from news.yahoo.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#106 - Specific pages from wikipedia.org are also displaying the right-hand infobox in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#107 - Superscript characters from wikipedia.org are always displayed at the right side of the string it's associated to

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#108 - Pages with reasonable amount of text from *.blogspot.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#109 - Pages with reasonable amount of text from *.about.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#110 - Pages with reasonable amount of text from *.craigslist.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#111 - The pages from huffingtonpost.com are missing their byline information in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-07: closed by Nicolas Perriault as fixed on fx-team and latest master

#112 - Specific pages from ehow.com are displaying the navigation menu in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-30: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#113 - Specific pages from ehow.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-29: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#114 - Most of the pages from theverge.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#115 - Specific pages from bbc.com cannot be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-07: closed by Nicolas Perriault (:n1k0) as fixed on fx-team and latest master

#116 - Reader View is available for wordpress.com/fresh although it shouldn't

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-27: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#117 - Reader View displays strings related to social widgets for specific wordpress blogs

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-14: closed by Gijs Kruitbosch (:gijsk) as fixed

#118 - Hero image missing from specific wordpress blogs

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#119 - Most of the pages from time.com either fail or can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-07: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-07: closed by Nicolas Perriault (:n1k0) as fixed on fx-team and latest master

#122 - Specific pages from mozilla.org that should be available in Reader View, in fact aren't

2015-04-08: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-14: closed by Gijs Kruitbosch (:gijsk) as invalid

#124 - Pages from reddit.com fail to be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-08: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#125 - Specific pages from usatoday.com are displaying image captions but not the image themselves in Reader View

2015-04-08: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-14: closed by Gijs Kruitbosch (:gijsk) as fixed

#126 - Specific pages from buzzfeed.com can't be displayed in Reader View

2015-04-08: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#134 - Reader View available for vimeo.com pages, but fails to display them

2015-04-10: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#151 - Pages from arstechnica.com are missing their subtitles in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#152 - Specific pages from techcrunch.com are displaying the wrong headline in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-21: closed as fixed, by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#153 - Pages from techcrunch.com are partially missing byline information in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#154 - Reader View is unavailable for pages with reasonable amount of text from engadget.com

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#155 - Hero image is missing from specific engadget.com pages in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#156 - Byline information missing from engadget.com pages in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#157 - Reader View is available for specific tumblr.com index pages

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#158 - Specific pages from tumblr.com are displaying their headline twice in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#159 - Specific pages from tumblr.com are displaying incorrect headlines

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-17: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#160 - The pages from cnet.com are missing their subtitles in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#161 - The pages from cnet.com are partially missing byline information in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#162 - Pages from cnet.com with video content are displaying player-related strings in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#163 - The pages from makeuseof.com are displaying their byline twice in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-17: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#164 - Specific pages from makeuseof.com are displaying the wrong headline in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-17: closed as fixed by n1k0

#165 - The pages from techspot.com are missing their byline in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-23: marked as a dupe of #156 by Mathieu Leplatre (leplatrem)

#166 - The pages from techspot.com are missing their hero image

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites

#168 - Specific pages from businessinsider.com are displaying incorrect headlines in Reader View

2015-04-17: filed in GitHub, found while testing high-traffic websites
2015-04-17: closed as fixed by Nicolas Perriault (n1k0)

#173 - Reader View should not be available for the *.yahoo.com index page

2015-04-21: filed in GitHub, found validating 38.0b6-build1, by Cornel Ionce
2015-04-23: closed as fixed by Gijs Kruitbosch (gijsk)

#174 - Parts of the headline are missing in Reader View for pages from webmd.com

2015-04-21: filed in GitHub, found validating 38.0b6-build1, by Cornel Ionce
2015-04-24: closed as fixed by Gijs Kruitbosch (gijsk)

#179 - https://get.adobe.com pages offers Enter Reader View option

2015-04-23: filed in GitHub by Petruta Rasa

#180 - Images missing from specific buzfeed.com pages in Reader View

2015-04-23: filed in GitHub by Petruta Rasa

#181 - Text and images missing from specific imdb.com pages in Reader View

2015-04-23: filed in GitHub by Petruta Rasa

#218 - Specific pages from washingtonpost.com are missing their byline information

2015-05-11: filed in GitHub by Bogdan Maris

#219 - Image is scaled differently for same washingtonpost article

2015-05-11: filed in GitHub by Bogdan Maris

#220 - France24.com missing content

2015-05-12: filed in GitHub by Bogdan Maris

Milestones

Firefox 38.0.5 Beta 1

Build 1 Build 2
Builds FTP, HTTP FTP, HTTP
ID 20150510205200 20150511143336
Changeset 32b69592b334 (pushlog) fff143cacb66 (pushlog)

Manual testing summary

  • Test coverage
    • Smoke testing — targeting the primary functionalities of the feature
    • Exploratory testing — targeting various other scenarios surrounding the main functionalities available, including negative and edge cases
  • Platform coverage
    • Windows 7 (x64)
    • Windows 8.1 (x86)
    • Mac OS X 10.9.5
    • Ubuntu 14.04 (x64)
  • Reported bugs for this build
    • [normal] Bug 1163519 - ReaderParent.jsm:95:12 throws an error in the Browser Console when clicking the "Enter Reader View" button from the Location Bar
    • [normal] Bug 1163526 - The Reader View promo panel is automatically dismissed
    • [normal] Bug 1163523 - Clicking the body of a page displayed in Reader View places a focus ring on it
    • [normal] [ https://bugzil.la/1163534 Bug 1163534] - AboutReader.jsm:248:0 throws an error in the console when closing an about:reader tab
    • [normal] Bug 1163577 - Enter Reader View button available in Pocket List page
    • [normal] Bug 1163589 - Pages don`t render correctly after exiting Reader View
    • [normal] #218 - Specific pages from washingtonpost.com are missing their byline information
    • [normal] #219 - Image is scaled differently for same washingtonpost article
    • [normal] #220 - France24.com missing content
  • Test results
    • Smoke test results:
Platform Results (report)
Windows 7 (x64)
[FAILED]
Windows 8.1 (x86)
[FAILED]
Mac OS X 10.9.5
[FAILED]
Ubuntu 14.04 (x64)
[FAILED]
  • Overall feature status after testing: [ON TRACK]
  • Recommendation from QA: [CONDITIONAL SIGN OFF] — pending the review of newly introduced bugs

Sign off

Criteria

  • All the test cases were executed.
  • All the blocker, critical, major bugs have been fixed.

Results

Merge to Aurora Sign-off

  • [DONE] Aurora 38 (2015-02-27).
    • There were no blockers found while testing this feature.
    • Manual testing covered Windows 7 (x64), Windows 8.1 (x86), Ubuntu 14.04 (x64) and Mac OS X 10.9.5.

Merge to Beta Sign-off

  • [DONE] Beta 38.0 (2015-03-30).
    • There were no blockers found while testing this feature. Detailed test results are available in this etherpad.
    • Manual testing covered Windows 7 (x64), Windows 8.1 (x64), Windows XP (x64), Ubuntu 14.04 (x86) and Mac OS X 10.9.5.
  • [ON TRACK] Beta 38.0.5 (yyyy-mm-dd)
    • [CONDITIONALLY SIGNED OFF] 38.0.5b1-build2 (2015-05-12)

Merge to Release Sign-off

  • [DISABLED] RC 38.0
  • [ON TRACK] RC 38.0.5